«The Windhover» (YouTube)
Tuesday October 18th 2011, 14:01 pm
Filed under: First Paper

 

Background Music: Edward Elgar, “Nimrod”

YouTube User keef1212: “Edward Elgar – Nimrod“

 

Audio Recording: Unknown reader, taken from Poetry Foundation.

 

Victorian Paintings:

Edward Charles Williams, Out Fishing.

Myles Birket Foster, Reed Gatherers.

William Holman Hunt, The Light of the World.

Frederic Leighton, David – Oh that I had the Wings of a Dove! For then I Would Fly Away and Be at Rest.

George Edward Lodge, A Peregrine Falcon on a Cliff Side.

Archibald Thorburn, A Greenland or Gyr Falcon.

Henry John Boddington, On the Hills, North Wales.

Herbert James Draper, The Lament for Icarus.

Edward Steel Harper, A Woodland Rivulet.

George Vicat Cole, The Heart of Surrey.

Herbert James Draper, Day and the Dawnstar.

John Linnell, Evening, Storm Clearing Off.

John Brett, The Lizard.

John Brett, The Garrison Walk, St Mary’s.

Frederic Leighton, Elijah in the Wilderness.

William Holman Hunt, Christ and Two Marys.

Herbert James Draper, Flying Fish.

  

Kestrel Footage:

YouTube User keirshepherd: “Kestrel Hovering at the International Centre for Birds of Prey“

YouTube User GoldfinchGarden: “Kestrel Hovers Then Eats His Prey“

YouTube User GoldfinchGarden: “One Kestrel“

YouTube User MrWalkerAki: “White Kestrel Flying (EOS 50D+EF400mm)“

 

Further Acknowledgements:

Victorian Landscape Art. Rehs Galleries, Inc.

Victorian Neoclassicism and Romanticism – World Classic Gallery.

Victorian Painting – The Victorian Web.

British Paintings.

Victorian Composers.

.

.

.

BACK TO «INTRODUCTION»

BACK TO «COVER PAGE»



A Biographical Overview
Monday October 17th 2011, 1:21 am
Filed under: First Paper

 

The purpose of this section is to provide an introductory glance, so to speak, on the life of Gerard Manley Hopkins, in order to draw a basic connection between his lifetime, his role as a “poet-priest” (in words of W. H. Gardner [1986: xiii]), and the analysis of The Windhover. By this, it follows that we will be acquainted, from a general perspective, with the issues and the circumstances of his life and his career, and this certainly will allow for a better reading and understanding of the poem with which we are concerned here. Obviously, it goes without saying that his biography will be much more fully developed and focused on in the forthcoming Second Paper of the course, considering that all his complete poems will be then the subject of analysis.

 

The following biographical summary has been fully quoted from the page Gerard Manley Hopkins: A Brief Biography, written by Glenn Everett and hosted at The Victorian Web:

 

«Gerard Hopkins was born July 28, 1844, to Manley and Catherine (Smith) Hopkins, the first of their nine children. His parents were High Church Anglicans (variously described as “earnest” and “moderate”), and his father, a marine insurance adjuster, had just published a volume of poetry the year before.

At grammar school in Highgate (1854-63), he won the poetry prize for “The Escorial” and a scholarship to Balliol College, Oxford (1863-67), where his tutors included Walter Pater and Benjamin Jowett. At one time he wanted to be a painter-poet like D. G. Rossetti (two of his brothers became professional painters), and he was strongly influenced by the aesthetic theories of Pater and John Ruskin and by the poetry of the devout Anglicans George Herbert and Christina Rossetti. Even more insistent, however, was his search for a religion which could speak with true authority; at Oxford, he came under the influence of John Henry Newman. Newman, who had converted from Anglicanism to Roman Catholicism in 1845, provided him with the example he was seeking, and in 1866 he was received by Newman into the Catholic Church. In 1867 he won First-Class degrees in Classics and “Greats” (a rare “double-first”) and was considered by Jowett to be the star of Balliol.

The following year he entered the Society of Jesus; and feeling that the practice of poetry was too individualistic and self-indulgent for a Jesuit priest committed to the deliberate sacrifice of personal ambition, he burned his early poems. Not until he studied the writings of Duns Scotus in 1872 did he decide that his poetry might not necessarily conflict with Jesuit principles. Scotus (1265-1308), a medieval Catholic thinker, argued (contrary to the teachings of St. Thomas Aquinas) that individual and particular objects in this world were the only things that man could know directly, and then only through the haecceitas (“thisness”) of each object. With his independently-arrived at idea of “inscape” thus bolstered, Hopkins began writing again.

In 1874, studying theology in North Wales, he learned Welsh, and was later to adapt the rhythms of Welsh poetry to his own verse, inventing what he called ” sprung rhythm.” The event that startled him into speech was the sinking of the Deutschland, whose passengers included five Catholic nuns exiled from Germany. The Wreck of the Deutschland is a tour de force containing most of the devices he had been working out in theory for the past few years, but was too radical in style to be printed.

From his ordination as a priest in 1877 until 1879, Hopkins served not too successfully as preacher or assistant to the parish priest in Sheffield, Oxford, and London; during the next three years he found stimulating but exhausting work as parish priest in the slums of three manufacturing cities, Manchester, Liverpool, and Glasgow. Late in 1881 he began ten months of spiritual study in London, and then for three years taught Latin and Greek at Stonyhurst College, Lancashire. His appointment in 1884 as Professor of Greek and Latin at University College, Dublin, which might be expected to be his happiest work, instead found him in prolonged depression. This resulted partly from the examination papers he had to read as Fellow in Classics for the Royal University of Ireland. The exams occured five or six times a year, might produce 500 papers, each one several pages of mostly uninspired student translations (in 1885 there were 631 failures to 1213 passes). More important, however, was his sense that his prayers no longer reached God; and this doubt produced the “terrible” sonnets. He refused to give way to his depression, however, and his last words as he lay dying of typhoid fever on June 8, 1889, were, “I am happy, so happy.”

Apart from a few uncharacteristic poems scattered in periodicals, Hopkins was not published during his own lifetime. His good friend Robert Bridges (1844-1930), whom he met at Oxford and who became Poet Laureate in 1913, served as his literary caretaker: Hopkins sent him copies of his poems, and Bridges arranged for their publication in 1918.

Even after he started writing again in 1875, Hopkins put his responsibilities as a priest before his poetry, and consequently his output is rather slim and somewhat limited in range, especially in comparison to such major figures as Tennyson or Browning. Over the past few decades critics have awarded the third place in the Victorian Triumvirate first to Arnold and then to Hopkins; now his stock seems to be falling and D.G. Rossetti’s rising. Putting Hopkins up with the other two great Victorian poets implies that his concern with the ” inscape” of natural objects is centrally important to the period; and since that way of looking at the world is essentially Romantic, it further implies that the similarities between Romantic and Victorian poetry are much more significant than their differences. Whatever we decide Hopkins’ poetic rank to be, his poetry will always be among the greatest poems of faith and doubt in the English language.»

 

 

On  the whole, the aspects which we should take into consideration for this particular analysis of The Windhover are his entering the Society of Jesus in 1868 and the burning of his poems, his poetic silence from 1868 to 1876, and his ordination as a Jesuit priest in 1877 (exactly the same year in which the poem was written).

.

.

BACK TO «COVER PAGE»

 



Sprung Rhythm
Sunday October 16th 2011, 18:31 pm
Filed under: First Paper

 

Saville asserts that “The Windhover is, of course, an example of sprung rhythm in full flight – in all senses of the phrase – ” (2000: 110) and even more, defends the argument that “sprung rhythm is a key element” in what she terms “Hopkins’s poetics of homoerotic asceticism” and that “his poetic innovations, and especially rhythmic experiments,  do indeed “do what nothing else can in their contexts”: they enable him to negotiate what might otherwise have been an unendurable nexus of competing cultural and personal imperatives” (2000: 1). In addition, she proposes the following transcription of the complete sprung rhythm contained in The Windhover (2000: 105):

 

 

I cáught this mórning’s mórning mínion, kíng-

dom of dáylìght’s dáuphin, dàpple-dáwn-dràwn Fálcon, ìn his ríding

Of the rólling lèvel úndernéath him stèady aír, and stríding

Hígh there, hòw he rúng upon the réin of a wímpling wíng

In his écstasy! then óff, òff fórth òn swíng,

As a skáte’s heel swèeps smóoth on a bów-bènd: the húrl and glíding

Rebúffed the bíg wínd. My héart in híding

Stírred for a bírd,—the achíeve òf; the mástery of the thíng!

 

Brute béauty and válour and áct, oh, áir, prìde, plúme, here

Búckle! AND the fíre that bréaks from thée thèn, a bíllion

Tímes tòld lóvelier, mòre dángerous, O mý chèvalíer!

 

No wónder of it: shéer plód màkes plóugh dòwn síllion

Shíne, and blúe-blèak émbers, áh my déar,

Fàll, gáll themsélves, and gásh góld-vermíllion.

.

.

Saville then goes on to provide a series of arguments to support her theory, that sprung rhythm is actually a prosodic device which Hopkins employs as a means to articulate his repressed (homoerotic) desires:

 

“We move from “a slow march” (l. 1), to “a quick step or double-time” (l. 2), to “a marcher’s changing step” (l. 3). This intensification is required not only at the level of description – the flight of the bird – but also, because of Hopkins’s cultivated mimesis, at the level of the speaker’s performance. In contrast, line 4 is sonorous and pleasurable. The strong stress with which each foot begins is, in this line, followed by unstressed syllables that decrease in number as the line progresses, roves over into line 5, and comes to rest after the word “ecstasy!”. I would argue that the pleasure here is experienced in the release from the regularity that gives the first lines their martial rigor. The outcome is an abandon whose effectiveness depends on the preceding discipline. In other words, to attain the effect of ecstasy and sublimity, there must be – in both rhythmic performance and semantic description – an investment of extreme energy. Although the limits of license and restraint are stretched, such vigorous rhythm does not go so far as to signal violation either semantically or rhythmically.” (2000: 106)

 

“In the sestet, with the Petrarchan turn, the straining tension and pleasurable release of the bird in flight – as well as the poetic mastery, religious passion, and physical ecstasy it suggests – are replaced by the effort of renunciation followed by the quiet gratification of spiritual reward. The dipody of sprung rhythm licenses Hopkins to list six nouns, all requiring stress and all representing dimensions of worldly glory to be renounced (beauty, valor, act, air, pride, plume). In the third, fourth, and fifth feet of line 9, roving over into the first foot of line 10, every syllable – six consecutive syllables if we include “oh” as slurred into the stress of “air” – receives stress, culminating in the verb “Buckle!” After this follows a rhythmic release (“Búckle! AND the fire that bréaks from thée thèn, a bíllion / Tímes”), which, like line 6 of the octave, has a predominance of three-syllabled feet, mostly with falling stress patterns, that produce a waltz-like rhythm. The economy of ascetic renunciation that brings the speaker the reward of a tender closeness to Christ is thus endorsed in the performance by the exertion of stressed rhythm that gives way to lilting release.” (2000: 108)

 

“In the second tercet the two images of plowing and smoldering embers are introduced. Line 12 (“No wónder of it: shéer plód màkes plóugh dòwn síllion”) contains a particularly high degree of stress. The sforzando on “wónder,” the clashing accents on “shéer plód,” and the secondary stress on “màkes” and “dòwn” all contribute to the unusual heaviness of this line, which only lessens in the following line (“Shíne, and blúe-blèak émbers, áh my déar”). Here, reference once again turns to Christ, and the unstressed syllables are used to heighten or foreground the intensity of the stressed “áh” and “déar.” While certainly, as [Edward] Stephenson observes,  this is another instance of Hopkins matching meter with meaning to give a sense of the laborious act of plowing (74), what is to my mind more intriguing is the ascetic economy at work here: the effort figured by plowing, performed bodily by the speaker in the weight of rhythmic stress, authorizes the reward of tender closeness to the beloved Christ. In other words, the linguistic figuration of spiritual joy is given a corporeal, erotic dimension through the performance of rhythmic release.” (2000: 109)

 

Therefore, as in previous aspects which have been analysed in The Windhover, sprung rhythm is yet again one of those devices which Hopkins puts to the service of his presumably intended purpose: rework and articulate the unacceptable nature of his (homoerotic?) desire within a discourse which is acceptable.

.

.

BACK TO «THE (HYPERTEXTUAL) WINDHOVER»

BACK TO «COVER PAGE»