Filed under: First Paper
On the whole, and as concluding remarks, I do believe that a homoerotic interpretation of The Windhover is legitimate, especially if a whole series of aspects as the ones we have developed in the paper are summed up and combined. However, this does not imply that its mainstream or customary, so to speak, common interpretation is misguided or slanted. Most probably, the simple truth is that in reality we are facing a combination of discourses, maybe both religious and homoerotic. Saville describes this ideological opposition in the following passage:
“To acknowledge the sensuality and eroticism in a sonnet like “The Windhover” seems to question its devotional and ascetic status. Up to now this dilemma has split Hopkins’s commentators into what appear to be two irreconcilable camps. On the one hand are those who draw attention to the highly sensual, sometimes homoerotic nuances in his poetry, often with the purpose of assimilating him into a genre of sexually dissident literature emergent in the mid- to late nineteenth century. On the other hand are those who feel it necessary to defend Hopkins against homoerotic interpretation, insisting on the minor significance, if not impossibility, of such resonances, given the resolutely devotional nature of his work.” (2000: 4)
Following a similar line, Saville explains that “Victorian culture was marked by an acute sensitivity to both the enabling and the debilitating capacity of ascetic practice, a double valence that scholars of Hopkins have overlooked” and since “Hopkins practiced strict ascesis, his commentators appear to feel obliged either to approve or to disapprove of his rigorous self-discipline” (2000: 12). The result of this ambivalence is, according to Saville, that “many idealize his allegiance to the Society of Jesus as the source of spiritual strength from which his eucharistic and Christological verse derived,” whereas “others decry monasticism as the regrettably oppressive regimen from which he was only able to escape occasionally through his sensuous (sometimes overtly homoerotic) verse” (2000: 12-13).
Yet, Saville very accurately points out that “the tendency of these perspectives to be mutually exclusive limits their effectiveness”, and therefore it follows that “we cannot be satisfied, for instance, with a reading of “The Windhover” that approves of the male speaker’s celebration of his beloved Christ yet regrets the self-sacrifice that produces such intense devotion; nor can we be quite convinced by a reading that insists on the purely spiritual significance of verbs such as “Buckle!” “breaks,” “Fall,” and “gall” and avoids acknowledging the sensual satisfaction implicit in this figuration of physical trial” (2000: 13). In any case, and however it may be, Saville points out an interesting distinction between homosexual and the so-called queer category:
“Centering on the way Hopkins situated himself in relation to the self-discipline imposed on men-desiring men by the norms of Victorian middle-class heterosexuality, I argue that ascetic practices that appear to mortify the flesh in the interests of spiritual invigoration may paradoxically prove sensually and erotically satisfying too. Because of this paradox, the rigorous ascesis that Hopkins practiced in both his poetry and his daily life militates against any simple inclusion of him in a homosexual literary subculture of the kind cultivated by his contemporaries. Nevertheless, the sensual effects of courtly poetry devoted to Christ as the beloved produce a charged affect that to a late-twentieth-century ear may seem homoerotic while to a late-Victorian sensibility may have signaled a strange distortion of manly energy.” (2000: 5)
In any case, my personal opinion is that The Windhover does admit a homoerotic interpretation, considering not only Hopkins’s poetic craft and use of stylistic devices and so forth, but also certain aspects belonging to his biography such as his sudden burning of his previous poems, his years of silence in poetry writing and above all, his later so-called “terrible sonnets”, which provide a perspective about his figure and his personality and works which allow for a questioning, or a query on whatever he regarded as permanent at certain points in his life (like his devotion to Christ in this particular poem). However, this last point leads me to the second part of my personal conclusion, that is that I strongly believe that to read Hopkins in homoerotic terms invariably implies a holistic reading as well. That is, to my mind, a single poem by Hopkins, like in this case The Windhover, cannot possibly be regarded as critically homoerotic without a holistic view in mind, without external references to Hopkins’s oeuvre. In my opinion, a homoerotic line of criticism of Hopkins only supports itself, and is reasonable only, within a holistic context (his complete poems), not in isolation (a single poem like The Windhover). I believe Hopkins is too obscure a poet as to signal qualities belonging to a critical field in only one of his artistic pieces (note, for instance, that particular aspects of this paper, such as the labour-devotional discourse or the use of sprung rhythm as a means of managing desire, cannot be fully explained without reference to other poems in his oeuvre). For that reason, I really look forward to the Second Paper of the course, which I hope will be satisfying for me and sustainable, both in terms of literary criticism.
.
.
Leave a comment
Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>