Submission
Wednesday November 30th 2011, 1:36 am
Filed under:
Second Paper
In close connection with the paradigms of Christ’s dominance, masochism and to some extent emasculation, Hopkins generally portrays himself in this selection of poems as a submissive subject, one which consciously submits himself to God/Christ’s will and consciously allows himself to be mastered by God/Christ. For example, in ‘Let me be to Thee as the circling bird,’ he asks to be allowed to be like a circling bird to God, thus God being the pivot point around which Hopkins/the bird circles. Hence, clearly submitting himself to the symbolic figure of God. Likewise, in The Wreck of the Deutschland Hopkins elaborates on this same paradigm with statements like “Thou mastering me / God! giver of breath and bread”, in which the poetic voice is clearly assuming a submissive and passive role. Similar examples of later poems could be: “Complete thy creature dear O where it fails, / Being mighty a master, being a father and fond” (In the Valley of the Elwy) or “You there are master, do your own desire;” (The Candle Indoors)..
.
.
«ANALYSIS BY INDIVIDUAL POEMS»
«ANALYSIS BY SUBJECT»
«COVER PAGE»
Dangerous/Undangerous Beauty
Wednesday November 30th 2011, 1:35 am
Filed under:
Second Paper
In several other poems, Hopkins elaborates on another binary opposition: that of beauty as dangerous or as undangerous. The of undangerous beauty can be seen in Moonrise, where a sudden sight of the moon at night is explored by an obvious lack of expressive obscurity, which puts a greater emphasis on the concept of dangerous beauty that is normally accompanied by some kind of linguistic distortion. Interestingly enough, this dangerous type of beauty is dealt with in more poems than its counterpart. The perfect embodiment of the dilemma springing from this dichotomy is found in To what serves Mortal Beauty? and also in The Leaden Echo and the Golden Echo. In ‘As kingfishers catch fire, dragonflies draw flame;’ or The Lantern out of Doors, Hopkins seems to articulate an implicit reference to this opposition, in a very close connection to the another dichotomy, that of human manly beauty/divine manly beauty. In a similar pattern, the poet speaks explicitly of human masculine beauty in Felix Randal (“his mould of man, big-boned and hardy-handsome”) yet the extent to which this description is dangerous is immediately lessened by a Christianising frame, which is probably the most effective and frequent device that Hopkins employs throughout the selection in order to neutralise the possibility of an erotic subtext. Lastly, in Epithalamion, a similar operation may be said to take place: Hopkins almost portrays himself as some kind of voyeur glancing at some boys swimming, yet my argument is that water acts as both a homoerotic symbol and a neutralising (religious) agent, so again the possible homoerotic subtext is lessened. On the whole, the importance of this paradigm lies, as in the case of darkness/light/blindness/sight, in the extent to which it proves that Hopkins was managing, throughout his lifetime, the clashing of two opposing sites, one to which he felt morally obliged and another to which he felt unmorally attracted.
.
.
«ANALYSIS BY INDIVIDUAL POEMS»
«ANALYSIS BY SUBJECT»
«COVER PAGE»
Sex/Masochism
Wednesday November 30th 2011, 1:35 am
Filed under:
Second Paper
As in the case of feminisation/emasculation, another striking feature of Hopkins’s poetics is that in a considerable group of poems from this selection, the poet occasionally portrays his relationship with God/Christ in overtly sexual and/or masochistic terms and imagery, in a clear connection with the subjects of Christ’s dominance and Hopkins’s submission. The reference is sometimes very slight indeed, as in ‘Let me be to Thee as the circling bird,’ (“I have found the dominant of my range and state”) or ‘Thou art indeed just, Lord, if I contend’ (“O thou lord of life, send my roots rain”). However, in other poems the sexual/masochistic referent is much more apparent: The Wreck of the Deutschland (“Thou mastering me / God! giver of breath and bread”, “fastened me flesh”, “I did say yes / O at lightning and lashed rod”, “Wring thy rebel”, “with fire in him forge thy will”, “melt him but master him still”), In the Valley of the Elwy (“God, lover of souls, swaying considerate scales, / Complete thy creature dear O where it fails, / Being mighty a master, being a father and fond”), The Candle Indoors (“You there are master, do your own desire”), (Carrion Comfort) (“since (seems) I kissed the rod, / Hand rather”, “the hero whose heaven-handling flung me, fóot tród / Me? or me that fought him? O which one? is it each one? That night, that year / Of now done darkness I wretch lay wrestling with (my God!) my God”). In any case, it seems quite reasonable to consider that at least some part of his poetry is infused to some extent with overt sexual connotations, and most importantly, since these sexual/masochistic connotations are always related to Christ/God, that the poet did indeed reappropriate the divine figure to articulate his homoerotic desire.
.
.
«ANALYSIS BY INDIVIDUAL POEMS»
«ANALYSIS BY SUBJECT»
«COVER PAGE»