Self-Hatred
Wednesday November 30th 2011, 1:37 am
Filed under:
Second Paper
Self-hatred and self-deprecation are themes most commonly associated to the ‘terrible sonnets’ of the year 1885, yet some early poems like In the Valley of the Elwy or The Candle Indoors could also be regarded as instances of anticipation. Other poems from the selection, like ‘I wake and feel the fell of dark, not day.’, Carrion Comfort) and ‘Thou art indeed just, Lord, if I contend’, do belong to the ‘terrible sonnets’ of 1885. The importance of this paradigm is that it enables us to see the possible psychological effects of Hopkins’s struggle at theoretically reconciling two opposites sites: homosexual attraction and religious devotion. A possible argument could be that Hopkins turned to religion and God to find comfort or to find an external agency (the Society of Jesus) that controlled him and restrained his homosexual impulse, and gradually and some years later, upon the realisation that his homosexual desire was not suppressed, came the self-hatred that infuse the ‘terrible sonnets’ of 1885, although as we have said, this psychological characteristic was already partially present in earlier poems..
.
.
«ANALYSIS BY INDIVIDUAL POEMS»
«ANALYSIS BY SUBJECT»
«COVER PAGE»
imitatio Christi
Wednesday November 30th 2011, 1:37 am
Filed under:
Second Paper
In some way subordinate to the major paradigm of Christianisation/moralisation, in The Lantern out of Doors or Felix Randal, Hopkins undertakes the operation of imitatio Christi, basically consisting of the imitation of Christ as a whole. In the case of The Lantern out of Doors, the poet depicts himself as willing to be made to the image and likeness of God, is willing to cleanse his sins by resembling as much as possible the divine figure: “Christ minds: Christ’s interest, what to avow or amend / There, éyes them, heart wánts, care haúnts, foot fóllows kínd, / Their ránsom, théir rescue, ánd first, fást, last friénd”. In contrast, Hopkins carries out the same process of imitatio Christi in the farrier of Felix Randal, not only through the notion of anointing Randal’s body (in connection with water as a homoerotic motif) but also by means of the recurrent emphasis on Randal’s suffering (as Christ himself suffered).
.
.
«ANALYSIS BY INDIVIDUAL POEMS»
«ANALYSIS BY SUBJECT»
«COVER PAGE»
Moonrise
Wednesday November 30th 2011, 1:36 am
Filed under:
Second Paper
I AWOKE in the Midsummer not-to-call night, | in the white
and the walk of the morning:
The moon, dwindled and thinned to the fringe | of a finger-nail
held to the candle,
Or paring of paradisaïcal fruit, | lovely in waning but lustreless,
Stepped from the stool, drew back from the barrow, | of dark
Maenefa the mountain;
A cusp still clasped him, a fluke yet fanged him, | entangled him,
not quit utterly.
This was the prized, the desirable sight, | unsought, presented so
easily,
Parted me leaf and leaf, divided me, | eyelid and eyelid of slumber.
.
.
Composed on June 19, 1876, at St. Beuno’s (and thus belonging to Hopkins’s Welsh sonnets), the inclusion of Moonrise within the selection of poems to analyse in the paper is basically due to its harsh contrast to other poems in the corpus such as ‘I wake and feel the fell of dark, not day’ and especially To what serves Mortal Beauty?. The opposition derives from the treatment of sight in relation to what Hopkins distinguished as dangerous or evil beauty, in contrast to that which was theoretically undangerous for him, and ultimately Hopkins’s frequent reliance on linguistic obscurity. One of my initial arguments concerning this question is that Hopkins consciously manipulated his sensory capacity by means of his poetry, from the inital dominance of the visual to an abrupt shift to the aural. One must only glance through his journal to notice his extreme sensitivity to the visual experience (comprising both natural phenomena, as in Moonrise, and the excessive stalling at boys and men which he regarded as dangerous and self-indulgent, as in To what serves Mortal Beauty?) and the way in which he reworked his visual capacity into aural requirements, by means of sprung rhythm, a heavy emphasis on the aural nature of poetry and his insistence on his poetic writings being made more to be heard than to be read, thus slightly displacing the visual scenario, yet quite interestingly maintaining the sensuous overtone that dominates his writings.
It is precisely this general parameter the one around which Vendler articulates her argument as to why does not Hopkins employ sprung rhythm in all of his mature poems, especially given that in strictly poetic terms it was such a revolutionary experiment. Even though this is strictly not my personal interpretation, I believe that Vendler’s argument is so compelling that it certainly deserves consideration. To begin with, Vendler presents the setting of her point:
“Why did Hopkins not use sprung rhythm in certain poems written after he had invented it? To answer this question, we must look, briefly, at a pure prelapsarian ‘aesthetic’ moment, one into which the ethical and the theological do not enter; it shows Hopkins exalted in a completely undangerous way. One June night in 1876 (as Hopkins tells the story in “Moonrise”), he awoke in the early hours of the morning and saw the waning moon rising from behind a dark mountain. The moon, luminous but lustreless against the white midsummer dawn, had not yet completelly detached itself from the silhoutted darkness of the mountain. Startled gently from drowsiness by the sight, Hopkins found himself open-eyed; (…).” (Vendler 1995: 28)
The answer to the question she posed at the very beginning of the above passage is quite straightforward for her: “The awakened poet sees not ‘a’ prized sight, not ‘a’ desirable sight, but ‘the’ sight desirable and prized. This is Hopkins’ paradigmatic description of the undangerous aesthetic moment of pure sensuousness as he knows it, the ‘heaven of desire’ achieved” (Vendler 1995: 28-29). Even more, some further insight into the rationale behind Moonrise establishes the previously mentioned comparison with To what serves Mortal Beauty?:
“A rapture which is not threatening, like moonrise, will allow, it is true, the penetration of its visual ecstasy by the categorizing intellect – “This was the prized, the desirable sight” – and it will even allow, pari passu with its sensuous description, a metaphorical glimpse of a theological archetype (here paradisal fruit set against a glimpse of an equally theological demonic dragon with flukes and fangs, jealous of light). But after these intellectual and metaphorical excursions, this poem can end (because the object of its gaze is ethically neutral and the moment of its gaze – nighttime – is one not claimed by priestly obligation) with the trance of the poet, abed, awake, enthralled, divided leaf from leaf in a receptive and enraptured state. Here, there is none of the nervous back-and-forth movement from stolen glance to thought to stolen glance to theology that we saw prompted by male bodies in “To what serves Mortal Beauty?”. The solacing rhythms and the ‘perfect number’ symmmetry of “Moonrise”; its gentle unspondaic aesthetic responsiveness; its peaceable intertwining of the visual, the theological, and the intellectual; and finally its cessation in rapt sensuous trance rather than in stern intellectual or ethical thought: all of these point to what the stylistic body of the untroubled Hopkinsian self ‘ought’ to be. A reader aware of the ravaged stylistic body of Hopkins’ later poems of torture feels a pang when encountering the symmetrical, untortured, ‘innocent’ metrical and linguistic body of this poem.” (Vendler 1995: 31)
Obviously then, there is no ‘real’ homoerotic nuance as such in Moonrise, but certainly this specific argument about desirable/undesirable sight complements well with all other parameters. The point here is that Hopkins is not afraid of looking, does not feel threatened of looking too much at the moon and does not portray the experience as one which should not occur: the vision of the moon is “the prized, the desirable sight”, the moon is not a dangerous object to look at, in contrast to the “dangerous mortal beauty” of To what serves Mortal Beauty? or the recurrent emphasis in many poems on the question of blindness versus sight in which, most interestingly, blindness is commonly regarded as desirable and sight as undesirable (as opposed to Moonrise). Therefore, due to all of this just outlined, Hopkins does not necessarily feel drawn towards linguistic obscurity (including sprung rhythm) to convey his thoughts and can express himself plainly to a certain extent.
NEXT POEM: ‘As kingfishers catch fire, dragonflies draw flame;’
PREVIOUS POEM: The Wreck of the Deutschland
.
.
«ANALYSIS BY SUBJECT»
«ANALYSIS BY INDIVIDUAL POEMS»
«COVER PAGE»