Holy/Homoerotic Water
Wednesday November 30th 2011, 1:40 am
Filed under: Second Paper

 

In some of the poems in this selection, Hopkins presents water as a dual symbol: as a homoerotic signifier, and simultaneously as a neutralising agent, in connection with the paradigm of Christianisation/moralisation. In Felix Randal, Hopkins speaks of the farrier’s body being “anointed”; in ‘Thou art indeed just, Lord, if I contend’, the poet requests God for rain for his roots (“O thou lord of life, send my roots rain”); and in Epithalamion, Hopkins describes a voyeuristic instance where he is glancing at a group of boys swimming in a pool, later deciding to bath himself alone in a nearby pool, thus enacting the symbolic connotation of water as both a homoerotic signifier (the water surrounds the boys, he then swims alone in water) and a neutralising agent (due to its religious connotation as a baptismal element). In other poems, water acts apparently only as a homoerotic referent. In ‘My own heart let me more have pity on; let’, it could be argued that water would represent the satisfaction of his homosexual desire if only the poet was able to (“or thirst can find / Thirst’s all-in-all in all a world of wet”), since he is thirsty yet surrounded by water, by “a world of wet”. Similarly, in To what serves Mortal Beauty?, Hopkins specifies his object of desire, broadens the contrast between “thirst” and “wet”, and speaks of “Those lovely lads once, wet-fresh”.

.

.

«ANALYSIS BY INDIVIDUAL POEMS»

«ANALYSIS BY SUBJECT»

«COVER PAGE»



Darkness/Light/Blindness/Sight
Wednesday November 30th 2011, 1:39 am
Filed under: Second Paper

    

To my mind, this is certainly one of the major themes in Hopkins’s poetry and one of the most representative of the possibility of an underlying homoerotic discourse, along with Christianisation. In almost every single poem of this selection, Hopkins establishes a binary opposition between both sets of concepts (light/sight as opposed to darkness/blindness), sometimes between light and darkness (as in The Candle Indoors), sometimes mentioning both sets, partially or entirely (‘I wake and feel the fell of dark, not day.’, The Lantern out of Doors or ‘My own heart let me more have pity on; let’) and exceptionally making only some brief reference to the subject, as in (Carrion Comfort). On other occasions, but not less importantly, only one of the binary components is put an emphasis on: sight as a sensory experience, which is notably stressed in a considerable group of poems (such as The Wreck of the Deutschland, ‘As kingfishers catch fire, dragonflies draw flame;’, Moonrise, Felix Randal, The Leaden Echo and the Golden Echo, To what serves Mortal Beauty? or Epithalamion). The key question in this recurrent parallelism is that Hopkins could be said to be operating on an inner dilemma, a confrontation between two opposing sites: one negative site, which tempts him and which he permanently tries to resist (the one which he wishes yet is unable to avoid); the other a positive site, which permanently tries to keem him away from any contact with the negative site (the one which he is willing to be in but feels to be constantly drawn away from). This paradigm, as such, is not strictly homoerotic in sense, but definitely supports the view that Hopkins was struggling to manage some kind of opposition within himself.   

 .   

 .   

 «ANALYSIS BY INDIVIDUAL POEMS»    

«ANALYSIS BY SUBJECT»    

«COVER PAGE»



Moralisation/Christianisation
Wednesday November 30th 2011, 1:39 am
Filed under: Second Paper

 

This is probably the paradigm which I have regarded as the most significant towards a possible homoerotic interpretation of Hopkins’s poetics. The truth is that in almost every poem (fourteen poems in total) of this selection, Hopkins elaborates on some kind of moralisation and/or Christianisation process that eventually frames the whole poem and implicitly, as a consequence, neutralises any possible immoral connotation (and within immoral connotations, we could find a homoerotic connotation). Curiously enough, this particular paradigm can be seen all throughout his poetic career: in pre-conversion poems like Heaven-Haven and ‘Let me be to Thee as the circling bird,’, in his return to poetry with The Wreck of the Deutschland and other mature poems like ‘As kingfishers catch fire, dragonflies draw flame;’, In the Valley of the Elwy, The Lantern out of Doors, The Candle Indoors, Felix Randal, The Leaden Echo and the Golden Echo, ‘I wake and feel the fell of dark, not day.’, To what serves Mortal Beauty? or (Carrion Comfort), and finally in latest works such as Epithalamion or ‘Thou art indeed just, Lord, if I contend’. The operation is largely the same in all fourteen poems: Hopkins posits some kind of comparison or contrast between an immoral thought, delving into it without no apparent obstacle, but immediately after resorts to a Christian element, or more broadly a moral or intellectual element, which is then overestimated, intensified and enhanced, thus underestimating the previous immoral statement. By means of this simple operation, Hopkins allows himself to work through a series of undesirable fields which are later rejected and replaced by the closing Christian or moral statement. However, no matter how intense the poet depicts that Christian/moral element, he has already been through the initial immorality, he has subconsciously (and even consciously) indulged into it and sinned, yet later, as easy as it gets, after confessing his sins, praises and theoretically prefers the closing Christianisation scenario and ends the poem being cleansed from all sinning. Therefore, as I said above, I believe this is probably the most significant paradigm from all being mentioned here. It could well be thought that Hopkins were using Christianity and religion as some kind of neutralisation agent in order to freely indulge into his immoral passion (homosexuality?) as an initial premise, later to admit his preference for a higher divine passion, as if resembling the ordinary stereotype of a penitent..

.

.

«ANALYSIS BY INDIVIDUAL POEMS»

«ANALYSIS BY SUBJECT»

«COVER PAGE»